Although voters’ assessments of the president’s performance have influenced their support for other candidates from his party in every midterm election, these elections have become more than ever a “referendum” on Donald Trump and his policies. Above all, his overall job approval rating has fallen to a record low of 30–32%, meaning that two-thirds disapprove of his performance. Over the past three decades, whenever a president’s disapproval rating exceeded his approval rating in an election year, his party lost control of the House of Representatives.
The influence of a president’s popularity on voter support for his party is nothing new. This time, however, a significant number of voters will cast their ballots specifically to remove “Trump’s party” from power. According to the PEW Research Center, they make up 44% of voters. Moreover, Trump is losing his former supporters. Polls show that many Americans who voted for him in 2024 regret their choice. Only two-thirds of those who voted for him then view his performance favorably now.
The most dramatic realignment in this campaign is Trump’s loss of two key voter groups that helped him win in 2024: Spanish-speaking Americans and young people. Among Latino voters, his net disapproval rating—the gap between negative and positive assessments—is 28%; among young people aged 18–29, it is 29%.
As in other campaigns over the past three decades, the economy is the main concern for Americans deciding which party to vote for: 84% said in polls that it was the top issue in the election. Among economic concerns, dissatisfaction with soaring prices for gasoline and other fuels has risen the most over the past six months. Most Americans link this to the failed war with Iran, launched by Trump in January, which led to the blockade of oil exports in the Persian Gulf. Ironically, four years ago, during the 2022 midterm elections, Trump traveled around the country campaigning for Republican candidates and accusing the Biden administration of presiding over a “catastrophic” spike in gasoline prices, which had topped $5 a gallon. Diesel now costs more than $6.50 a gallon and is still rising, and Americans blame the Republican administration and Trump.
The second most important issue in this election is corruption in government, especially in the Trump administration. This view has taken hold over the past year, as the president’s family income—including income from international “deals”—has exceeded $2 billion, and congressional investigations into it are being prepared.
Trump made illegal immigration the centerpiece of his 2024 presidential campaign, promising to close the border and deport all undocumented immigrants. His aggressive deportation campaign has prompted protests from many voters, including Latinos. More than half of Americans believe immigrants should be given the opportunity to obtain citizenship through legal channels. Only 43% think Trump is making the right decisions on immigration.
Most Americans view the Trump administration’s actions on health care, access to affordable medical services, and insurance negatively. Although abortion rights are no longer as important to voters as they were in the 2022 midterms, they still influence assessments of the administration, and most people do not think Trump is making the right decisions on this issue.
Americans have generally been critical of Trump’s “trade war”—the imposition of sweeping tariffs on foreign goods. Democrats and Republicans are roughly evenly divided on whether tariffs could boost employment, but a majority—six in ten—believe the tariffs have only driven up prices in the United States. Overall, 60% are critical of Trump’s ability to negotiate favorable trade agreements with other countries.
During Donald Trump’s one and a half terms as president, Americans have viewed his foreign-policy moves skeptically; only 35% rate his ability to make the right foreign-policy decisions positively. Voters rate his ability to use American military force judiciously just as poorly.
His judgment was on display in the war with Iran—the “Epic Fury” operation—which was conceived as yet another “small, victorious war” and aimed to eliminate Iran’s nuclear capabilities, replace the ayatollahs’ regime, and destroy its missile arsenal. The goals were not fully achieved. Iran suffered heavy losses, but its government remained in power; Iran gained control of the Strait of Hormuz, and global oil prices rose by a quarter. For America, the outcome was a failure. Today, 68% of Americans believe the war was not worth the cost to the country, and 49%—the same share as before the war began—consider Iran’s nuclear program a serious threat.
Voters’ assessments of the two years of Donald Trump’s administration are mostly critical. Polls show that Americans are dissatisfied with the economy, declining living standards, and health care. Criticism of Trump’s dictatorial tendencies, his pursuit of the critical press and political opponents, and his violations of constitutional norms and laws has been less prominent. Still, this criticism has surfaced in the “No Kings” protest marches, which drew 7 million and 5 million participants. It has also appeared in recent polls, where “the future of democracy” was named as one of the main concerns. To a considerable extent, a refusal to elect Republican candidates in these elections would amount to a vote of no confidence in “Trumpism”—Donald Trump’s policies, principles, and authoritarian governing style over his one and a half presidential terms.
For the past two years, political debate in the United States has revolved around one question: how assessments of Trump’s presidency and his popularity among voters would affect the election and the makeup of Congress. After November 3, the question will be reversed: how will the new makeup of the two chambers of Congress affect Donald Trump’s fate, given that he is likely to face impeachments and court proceedings? Another question of no less interest is how Trump’s authoritarianism will function with Democrats in control of Congress.